Politics & Government

Lawyers Argue Before Judge On La Grange Building Demolition

A judge is asked whether the village acted in contempt of a court order barring a teardown.

A crew on Monday prepares to demolish the old Jackson Square antique mall building at 112 E. Burlington Ave. in La Grange.
A crew on Monday prepares to demolish the old Jackson Square antique mall building at 112 E. Burlington Ave. in La Grange. (David Giuliani/Patch)

LA GRANGE, IL – The demolition of a historic building in La Grange continued Tuesday while lawyers argued over whether it should.

In May, Cook County Court Judge Renee Jackson issued a temporary restraining order, barring the teardown of the old Jackson Square antique mall building at 112 E. Burlington Ave.

On Monday morning, the developer, Five South Six, started the demolition about a month after Jackson dismissed it as a defendant.

Find out what's happening in La Grangefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

The village remained a defendant in the lawsuit filed by Jonathan Robinson, who lives next to the building.

La Grange's attorney, Ben Schuster, said the village has no power to stop the teardown.

Find out what's happening in La Grangefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

He acknowledged the village issued a demolition permit in June, a few weeks after the court order.

But he said the village was required to issue it because the project met the local code. If the village had done otherwise, the developer would have sued, he said.

Robinson's attorney, Christian Ketter, argued that a village's duty does not override a court order.

"The village was the gateway to the demolition," he said.

He said he wanted the court to determine whether the village acted in contempt of the judge's order.

Schuster said Ketter has not once asserted the demolition itself was illegal.

"Instead, Mr. Ketter told me earlier today he filed this because he was afraid of a malpractice claim," Schuster said.

Ketter objected to Schuster's "shameful comment."

"I will only say that I will not repeat the words Mr. Schuster said on that phone call," Ketter said.

Jackson said she found the matter to be an emergency, as Ketter had requested.

She said she would rule by Friday, likely earlier, on Ketter's request for clarification on her temporary restraining order on the demolition.

Five South Six's Dan Spain, owner of La Grange's The Elm restaurant, plans to build a 39-unit, five-story condo complex after the demolition.

In his lawsuit, Robinson alleged the village failed to adhere to minimal setbacks and loading space requirements.

He also contended the village failed to give him a "meaningful opportunity" to say how the proposed complex would pose a hardship on his property.

The village maintained it followed the law.

In January, the Village Board voted unanimously for the teardown and condo complex. Many residents objected to demolishing the historic building.

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.