Restaurants & Bars

'No Tips, No Gluten And No Drama': Plainfield Bakehouse Prepares To Sell Bagels, Sourdough On Lockport Street

Two friends, bakers and business partners are getting ready to open their first brick-and-mortar business, mostly bakery and some bookstore.

Kim Whisenhunt (left) and Michaela Gallaher pose for a photo in front of their new bakery, Plainfield Bakehouse, on Lockport Street in the village's historic downtown.
Kim Whisenhunt (left) and Michaela Gallaher pose for a photo in front of their new bakery, Plainfield Bakehouse, on Lockport Street in the village's historic downtown. (Courtesy Michaela Gallaher)

PLAINFIELD, IL — Imagine it's Saturday, the air crisp but fresh, and orange and chartreuse leaves are still hanging on soon-to-be-barren trees. Your ideal morning is a walk down historic, charming streets followed by a handmade bagel, a freshly brewed cup of coffee and a good used book.

Soon, that can be a reality, thanks to friends, business partners and Plainfield natives Kim Whisenhunt and Michaela Gallaher, who are on the cusp of opening Plainfield Bakehouse on Lockport Street in downtown Plainfield.

The business will take over the retail space in between Prudential Advisors and A&M Esthetics Spa. The storefront has a history of housing bakeries, with Milette's Cakes having been the previous tenant before closing earlier this year.

Find out what's happening in Plainfieldfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Plainfield Bakehouse is poised to be a unique offering to the village's steadily booming historic downtown district. Each owner will bake and sell their own specialties — Whisenhunt, bagels, and Gallaher, sourdough breads and sweets — while using part of the front-of-house space as a used bookstore.

How the pair became owners of a brick-and-mortar bakery was a matter of need and chance. Whisenhunt owns Blue Heron Bagels, and Gallaher runs Gallaher Sourdough — it's through their baking endeavors that they met. Whisenhunt, until Plainfield Bakehouse, worked as a teacher for the deaf and hard-of-hearing, while Gallaher ran her cottage bakery full-time.

Find out what's happening in Plainfieldfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Each achieved the dreams of many: Their demand skyrocketed to the point of selling out, sometimes within 30 minutes, they told Patch. It's part of what drove each to want to expand and find a commercial kitchen to share.

"I was against the idea a storefront forever," Gallaher said. "It was only this summer, when my demand got unbearable. It became no longer fun because everyone was upset they couldn't get bread. ... Because of that, I was more open to the idea."

For Whisenhunt, she said, "it just didn't make sense to put time and money into equipment or building out the home bakery because at that point, with bagels, you can't do cream cheese from your home, and so I was already looking at going into a commercial kitchen. ... Someone brought this up to me, and I was like, 'You know what, maybe I want to switch altogether."

Whisenhunt and Gallaher began dreaming up the business idea in August and jumped at the chance to take over the storefront at 24042 W. Lockport St. when it became available, knowing it was the right location for them, they said. They signed the lease Sept. 15 and are now hoping to soft-open the business in December.

"To find a historic building where there is a history of bakeries here, and it's in the heart of downtown, all of the pieces fit together so well," Gallaher said. "To be able to create a world where people get to join us in person ... I can't imagine how much more rewarding it will be for people to come in and meet our employees ... these people are a dream."

Whisenhunt echoed her business partner and added: "I think once we saw the building, we were like, 'We don't care, we want it.'"

The business model is further unique because the owners share Plainfield Bakehouse, but each baker will operate their own business and have separate baking staff, but they'll partner on the front-of-house operations and share profits from coffee, books and merchandise.

"When we were talking about this whole thing, the Bakehouse, I proposed it as, 'Do you want to move in together into a shared kitchen kind-of-a-thing?'" Gallaher said. "It's a little hybrid."

The idea to sell used books was a "brainchild" of Gallaher's, Whisenhunt said. It fills a gap in the downtown district's offerings, currently missing a business that gives life to well-loved books.

"When I think about what's super welcoming in addition to just a bakery, [it's] a wall of books that you can buy that's cheaper than buying it new, but you also get to own it," Gallaher said. "It adds to the experience to find a good book to read. You can stay and read while you have a bagel with cream cheese or coffee."

Plainfield Bakehouse plans to open at 24042 W. Lockport St. before the year's end. (Courtesy Michaela Gallaher)

Being doors down from the popular Krema Coffee House, the coffee shop and Plainfield Bakehouse partnered to craft a morning blend for the bakery. Whisenhunt and Gallaher explained they don't want to compete with Krema but rather foster community.

"We'll always be a business that gives back in some capacity," Whisenhunt said. One way: Plainfield Bakehouse won't accept tips.

"We believe in, one, paying our employees a fair wage and not making them depend on tips, which are inconsistent," Gallaher said. "If somebody wants to tip us, we ask them to donate that money to the Plainfield Food Pantry, and/or review us on Google, like give us an honest review. Don't give us more money."

Before opening, owners also wanted to put to bed the question of gluten-free offerings.

"We love the gluten-free community so much that we will not be baking something that is potentially hazardous to them," Gallaher said. "It's also not legal to produce something gluten-free in a kitchen full of gluten. We will be referring people to other actually gluten-free bakeries in the area when you ask that in person."

"No tips, no gluten and no drama," the pair said amid shared laughter.