Community Corner
Teatotaller's $100 Court Win Costs Meta Immunity
The tech giant behind Facebook and Instagram potentially lost more when it lost the small claims lawsuit brought by Emmett Soldati.

The tech giant behind Facebook and Instagram potentially lost more than $100 when it lost the small claims lawsuit brought by Emmett Soldati, owner of Teatotallerβs Cafe.
Mark Zuckerbergβs Meta also lost immunity under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, the law frequently used to shield social media companies from legal consequences.
Find out what's happening in Concordfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
βThis judgment is definitive that Facebook is not immune,β Soldati told InDepthNH.org.
Soldatiβs been fighting Meta for years since the company deleted Teatotallerβs Instagram page without any reason. He went up against Metaβs high-priced lawyers and represented himself in court, even taking the case to the New Hampshire Supreme Court.
Find out what's happening in Concordfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The result of his labors was Dover District Court Judge Sawako Gardnerβs ruling this month that states the company did have a contract with Teatotallerβs.
Gardnerβs ruling finds the terms of service agreement users sign when they create their social media accounts on Instagram have the legal force of contracts. When Meta deleted Teatotallerβs account in violation of the terms, it was breaking its contract with Soldatiβs business.
This represents a major legal change to the way Meta is used to operating, according to Soldati.
βMeta counsel tried to claim itβs a free service and they do not owe users anything. You are making a promise to provide this account, absolutely this is a contract,β Soldati said.
The other big change for Meta in Gardnerβs ruling is that the company cannot avoid certain lawsuits using the federal Decency in Communications Act.
Section 230 of the Decency in Communications Act has been used to protect social media companies from getting sued when users post defamatory content, Gardner found that Meta could not use Section 230βs protections to stop Soldatiβs lawsuit.
βSocial media companies have used Section 230 to dismiss case after case after case,β he said.
Teatotallerβs Instagram account was deleted without notice in 2018. Soldati said his business never violated any of Metaβs terms of service which would result in a deletion, and he never got an explanation from the company.
Soldati was able to create a new account five days later, but he lost the follower base he had spent years building on the social media platform. Soldati used the Instagram page as a digital storefront for Teatotallerβs and the loss of his original account hurt his bottom line, he said.
Meta did not respond to a request for comment. According to court documents, the company offered no explanation for the deletion, and representatives told the court it did not need a reason.
Teatotallerβs business is known for its progressive embrace of social issues, including its celebration of the LGBTQ+ community. The business was targeted last year by neo-Naziβs when it hosted a drag queen story hour. The New Hampshire Attorney Generalβs Office is seeking Civil Rights violation charges against members of neo-Nazi group NSC-131 for the incident.
Soldati does not think his businessβs pro-LGBTQ+ position is behind the deletion. He blames incompetence.
βI donβt believe that to be the case. I think itβs more likely Facebookβs technology failed,β he said.
Gardnerβs ruling awards Soldati $100 in damages plus $145 in court costs. Heβs currently seeking a clarification order, as heβs spent a lot more than $245 with Meta. But, his case was about more than the money, it was about forcing the company to admit it was in the wrong.
βItβs always been about standing up for something so simple,β Soldati said.
This story was originally published by InDepth NH.