Politics & Government
Will A Partisan Democrat As New Hampshire Secretary Of State Endanger The FITN?
NH SOS David Scanlan: "The secretary of state must be fully committed to upholding the 108-year-old time-honored tradition."

The three Democrats who’ve announced they’re running for Secretary of State have focused their messaging on expanding ballot access and advocating for more lenient voting rules.
But for many Granite Staters involved in politics, the top concern is the Secretary of State’s vital role in protecting the endangered First-in-the-Nation primary.
Find out what's happening in Hampton-North Hamptonfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Are these Democrats willing to take on their own national party to protect the primary? Or will an openly-partisan Secretary of State, something New Hampshire hasn’t had in half a century, endanger the FITN?
“The secretary of state must be fully committed to upholding the 108-year-old time-honored tradition,” current Secretary of State David Scanlan told NHJournal. “There is a lot more to that role than just setting the date. It can be a lonely responsibility requiring patience and a resolute ability to withstand enormous political pressure that may come from within your own party.”
Find out what's happening in Hampton-North Hamptonfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Scanlan’s predecessor, Democrat Bill Gardner, spent roughly four decades garnering headlines as a staunch defender of the state’s presidential primary.
“No matter what threat is raised, no matter what pressure is wielded, no matter what maneuver is tried by another state, he said he would not give way on what he described as the principal charge of his office: protecting the sanctity of New Hampshire’s status as first to hold a full-fledged primary,” read a New York Times profile of Gardner in 2007.
Unlike most states, New Hampshire’s secretary of state is not elected at the ballot box, but rather by the 424 members of the state House and Senate by secret ballot in a joint session on Organization Day, Dec. 2, when lawmakers elected on Nov. 3 are sworn in.
Today, Democratic candidates Carleigh Beriont of Hampton, Rep. Patrick Long of Manchester and James Butler of Portsmouth represent a party that is increasingly disillusioned with the importance of the primary itself.
A February 2026 UNH Survey Center poll found that just 49% of self-identified Granite Democrats supported the law protecting New Hampshire’s first-in-the-nation status, compared with 76% of Republicans. Forty-one percent of Democrats remained neutral or said it did not matter to them.
Former Democratic U.S. Rep. Dick Swett said that the DNC’s recent decision to strip New Hampshire of its first-in-the-nation status further complicates matters for the next secretary of state.
“We have had Republican houses with lopsided majorities who elected Democrat Bill Gardner as secretary of state. He did a wonderful job defending the first-in-the-nation primary and that’s been so important,” Swett told NHJournal. “With the national Democratic Party taking its positions opposing New Hampshire’s FITN primary, I’m not sure that a partisan Democrat will be as effective in the job.”
Beriont, who is chair of the Hampton Board of Selectmen and ran during the recent midterm cycle as an NH-01 congressional candidate, and Butler, who previously served as a policy adviser for Gov. Maggie Hassan, are both supportive of the state’s presidential primary.
Butler listed defending the primary alongside efforts to “modernize” the role and “expand voting rights” in his letter to lawmakers announcing his run last week.
When reached by NHJournal, Beriont provided the letter that she shared with lawmakers where she pledged to support the state’s first-in-the-nation presidential primary.
“While our state law keeps New Hampshire’s primary first, over the long run, candidates will only continue to campaign here if the country sees our elections as worthy of that distinction,” Beriont wrote. “As secretary of state, I am committed to upholding our tradition and serving as a model for the rest of the country. By modernizing local voting equipment, ensuring transparent procedures and removing excessive barriers to participation, we can do democracy better.”
In April, shortly after launching her congressional bid, Beriont defended the primary against critics who argued that New Hampshire’s lack of racial diversity should prohibit it from going first with an op-ed in the Union Leader titled, “Why should NH be first? It works.”
“Critics point out, fairly, that New Hampshire doesn’t look like America,” Beriont wrote. “We’re not as diverse as the country whose candidates we claim to vet first. But the first primary was never meant to be a demographic mirror; it’s a stress test.”
While Beriont and Butler position themselves as continuing the legacy left by Scanlan and Gardner, Long has declined to share details about his position on the state’s presidential primary.
Long, meanwhile, has released his ambitions for the office, including some which extend beyond the office’s authority, such as enabling online voter registration and encouraging the Legislature to pass broader absentee voting laws.
The Manchester representative declined NHJ’s request for clarifications of his position on the first-in-the-nation presidential primary.
As Organization Day approaches, Scanlan said that he remains confident about his odds, citing Democratic support.
Former Democratic state Rep. James Splaine, who authored the 1975 measure which enshrined New Hampshire’s first-in-the-nation primary into state law, is one of those Democrats backing Scanlan.
“I think Scanlan is primed to do it best, but I accept the fact that there can be someone else,” Splaine told NHJournal. Splaine added that he believed any of the candidates elected would “understand that one of their most important duties is to protect the primary.”
Yet, when asked what advice he would give the next incoming secretary of state, Splaine offered only four words: “Talk to Bill Gardner.”
This story was originally published by the NH Journal, an online news publication dedicated to providing fair, unbiased reporting on, and analysis of, political news of interest to New Hampshire. For more stories from the NH Journal, visit NHJournal.com.