Politics & Government

Win Or Lose, Tax Cap Supporters See Manchester Recount As Victory

Manchester's school tax cap supporters are heading into a recount with a chance to turn a narrow defeat, 59.94%, into a victory.

The Nov. 3 tally showed 20,827 votes for Question 2 and 13,919 against, giving the proposal 59.94% support—just below the 60% required for adoption.
The Nov. 3 tally showed 20,827 votes for Question 2 and 13,919 against, giving the proposal 59.94% support—just below the 60% required for adoption. (NH Journal)

Manchester’s school tax cap supporters are heading into Friday’s recount with a chance to turn a narrow defeat into a victory. But petitioner Rich Girard says nearly 60% support already sends City Hall a message about reining in taxes.

The Nov. 3 tally showed 20,827 votes for Question 2 and 13,919 against, giving the proposal 59.94% support—just below the 60% required for adoption.

Find out what's happening in Manchesterfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

“More people voted for adopting this cap on school taxes and spending than have voted in the last several city elections,” Girard told NHJournal. “Adoption of Question 2 would be a much-needed win-win-win for Manchester’s taxpayers, who sent a clear message about reining in taxes.”

Girard, a former alderman and at-large school board member, and 10 other voters petitioned for the recount Nov. 10. It is scheduled to begin at 8 a.m. Friday, Nov. 20, at the Manchester School District Welcome Center, 148 Concord Street.

Find out what's happening in Manchesterfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Question 2, placed on general election ballots statewide by HB 1300, asks voters to adopt limits on local school property tax growth and school administrative unit central office spending. Adoption is determined by the combined vote within each school district and SAU, rather than the statewide total.

If adopted, the local school property tax levy would be limited to the prior year’s amount, adjusted for inflation and qualifying growth in the taxable property base, including new construction. SAU central office administrative spending would be capped at 6% of total school district appropriations, excluding qualifying bonded capital costs. The caps would apply for two years beginning with the fiscal 2028 budget.

Alderman Joe Kelly Levasseur, an attorney representing Girard and the other petitioners, argues that adopting the measure would give taxpayers another protection against tax increases.

“Twenty-one votes is definitely worth a recount. Eleven out of 12 wards supported it, and it barely lost,” Levasseur told NHJournal. “The restrictions placed on this tax cap may be better, in some instances, than the city tax cap, especially if Mayor Ruais tries to allow another override. This tax cap may take precedence.”

The proposal received more “yes” votes than “no” votes in 11 of Manchester’s 12 wards, but adoption requires 60% support citywide. The initial tally fell about 0.06 percentage points short.

Manchester already has a municipal tax cap, with its current language approved by voters in 2011. It limits growth in spending and property tax revenue using the average annual change in the Consumer Price Index over the previous three calendar years, with provisions accounting for new construction.

The Board of Mayor and Aldermen voted 11-3 in June to override that cap and approve a $448 million city and school budget.

Opponents of Question 2, including Democratic U.S. Sen.-elect Chris Pappas and Ward 1 Alderman Bryce Kaw-uh, point to the city’s existing cap as a reason to reject the additional restrictions.

“There’s a lot of pressure on the local property tax right now, and communities are forced to make tough choices,” Pappas said during his WMUR debate against Republican John Sununu. “I vote in Manchester, and we have a tax cap in place in Manchester, so I’ll be voting against this, and I really think people in their local communities should think about what’s important.”

“I felt that Question 2 would unnecessarily complicate the budget process for Manchester, where we already have a tax cap that is stricter than what Question 2 would mandate,” Kaw-uh told NHJournal.

Manchester School District attorney Matthew Upton said the central office spending limit is the biggest difference between the two caps. He estimated the district’s current administrative spending at about 4.5% of its budget.

“The district believes that in almost all conceivable circumstances the Manchester tax cap will be more restrictive than the HB 1300 tax cap given that the Manchester tax cap applies to both revenue and expenditures,” Upton told NHJournal. “Nonetheless, if the [HB 1300] tax cap passes on the recount—and is not successfully challenged in court—the district will run tax cap calculations to ensure that the more restrictive tax cap will be applied.”

Statewide, Question 2 received 59% support. Majorities backed the measure in all 10 counties and 21 of the state’s 24 Senate districts, though passage depends on school district and SAU totals.

A Nov. 14 recount in Nashua confirmed the measure’s defeat there. The recount found 18,895 votes in favor and 13,244 opposed, or 58.79% support, below the required 60%. The recount added 66 “yes” votes and nine “no” votes to the original tally.

Kaw-uh said he trusts Manchester election officials to deliver an accurate result.

“Our election officials here in Manchester run a tight ship, and I have complete confidence in their work,” Kaw-uh told NHJournal. “Of course, when the results are close, it’s understandable that folks want to be 100% sure.”

Girard also said the narrow margin warrants checking the count.

“While the election ran smoothly overall, it wasn’t without its hiccups in several wards,” Girard said. “A recount provides scrutiny that should be welcomed by all parties to determine the accuracy of the new machines and ensure that no hiccup-affected ballots were missed.”


This story was originally published by the NH Journal, an online news publication dedicated to providing fair, unbiased reporting on, and analysis of, political news of interest to New Hampshire. For more stories from the NH Journal, visit NHJournal.com.