Politics & Government
Caldwell Will Get New Mayor, 2 Council Members: See Official Election Results
The Democratic candidates narrowly edged out their Republican counterparts in Caldwell's 2026 election.
CALDWELL, NJ — Get ready for a new mayor and two new council members in Caldwell.
On Wednesday, the Essex County Clerk’s Office released official results for the 2026 general election, including updated totals for local contests in Caldwell.
Kenneth Jurgensen, the Democratic challenger, has edged out Republican incumbent Garrett Jones in a close race for mayor, results show.
Find out what's happening in Caldwellsfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Meanwhile, the Democratic borough council candidates, Jonathan Sagalow and Mark Heftler – who ran on a slate with Jurgensen – have defeated Republican candidates, Andrew Pollara and Brian Bambrick, who ran on a slate alongside Jones.
Here are the official results from the clerk’s office:
Find out what's happening in Caldwellsfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
MAYOR
- Kenneth Jurgensen – 1,652 votes, 52.11%
- Garrett Jones – 1,518 votes, 47.89%
BOROUGH COUNCIL
- Jonathan Sagalow – 1,631 votes, 26.03%
- Mark Heftler – 1,605 votes, 25.61%
- Andrew Pollara – 1,526 votes, 24.35%
- Brian Bambrick – 1,504 votes, 24.0%
Jones launched his re-election campaign last spring alongside Pollara, the borough’s fire chief, and Bambrick, a member of the local planning board. MORE: Caldwell Mayor Launches Re-Election Campaign, Names 2 Council Running Mates
Jurgensen initially launched his campaign alongside Sagalow, an urban planner, and Ricardo Alcorta, a finance and accounting professional. After Alcorta withdrew from the council race due to family circumstances, he was replaced on the ticket by Heftler, an attorney.
The newly revamped Jurgensen-Sagalow-Heftler ticket, dubbed “Caldwell Forward,” posted a joint message after Election Night, saying they expected their lead to hold.
“In the meantime, we will begin planning the next steps necessary to ensure a smooth and seamless transition,” the slate said.
Republicans will still maintain a 4-2 majority on the borough council in Caldwell.
Send local news tips and correction requests to eric.kiefer@patch.com. Learn more about advertising on Patch here. Find out how to post announcements or events to your local Patch site.