Community Corner
Revitalized, Historic General Store Gets Immense Support From Long Valley
It's been just a few weeks since the 200-year-old store reopened, and the community is rallying behind its new owners.

LONG VALLEY, NJ — It's been roughly a month since one of the state's oldest general stores was reopened after about a year of being empty, and the Long Valley community is rallying behind its new owners.
On Oct. 17, Mark and Maria Broadhurst of Schooley’s Mountain Confection Company officially reopened the Schooley’s Mountain General Store after it closed last year.
The store, thought to have opened in the early 1800s, operated for literal centuries until its abrupt closure in 2025, an event that disappointed regulars called "the end of an era."
Find out what's happening in Long Valleyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Located at 250 Schooley's Mountain Road, it was home to the area’s oldest U.S. Post Office and holds a prominent place in local history—having hosted visits from former U.S. Presidents including Ulysses S. Grant, William Henry Harrison, and Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Until last year, it had been serving locals with snacks, groceries, meals, coffee, pizza, and plenty more.
Find out what's happening in Long Valleyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Now, thanks to the Broadhursts, the store is up and running once more, and the community has been extremely supportive, they say.
Regulars have not only been giving the store business (so much so that it has run out of product now and again), but are gifting trinkets and mementos to the Broadhursts that are being displayed in the store.
"Our family at the moment, we are the current stewards of this store, and it's an honor, it's a privilege, and there have been generations of families who have done so much for this little old store on the mountain... Keeping this going is paramount to the livelihood and success of our mountain top community," Mark said. "But one thing has become clear: This store is not ours; this is everyone's... There's a sentimental attachment to this store that has been truly heartwarming to feel and to witness every single day."
The shop has been offering coffee, homemade baked goods, a variety of sandwiches (they say the "Turkey Trot" Thanksgiving sandwich has been a hit so far), and more to hungry customers looking both for a bite and to support a beloved local business.
The store also offers locally made products, not just food, but locally-crafted soaps, lotions, and more available for sale.
"So happy to have a sandwich shop here again," one social media user wrote. "My roast beef sandwich was great. Best wishes for a long, successful residency."
"I popped in (finally!) and had the best caramel apple of my life! English toffee," wrote another. "The team at work was lovely and kind, and I’m so proud to be a part of this community and support the store."
Mark also provided some updates, saying the store will soon have a Google-listed phone number (for take-out orders), offer new bread options, and will soon sell breakfast sandwiches in addition to deli sandwiches.
"I just want to thank this community for their love of this store," Mark said. "This store belongs to you as much as it does me, my wife, and my family. This store belongs to all of us, so thank you for making it so special."
The store is open 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Friday, 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. Saturday, and 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Sunday.
The store is looking for full- and part-time help in the kitchen, and interested applicants can drop resumes off at the store or email them to mark@mymountainsweets.com.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.