Politics & Government

PSE&G Substation Plan Hits Roadblock In Montclair

"Ultimately, I do believe we will have to make some very tough decisions," the town's mayor said.

MONTCLAIR, NJ — A redevelopment plan that would have laid the foundation for several new uses of Montclair’s municipal building – including a new PSE&G substation – is off the table for now.

Talks have been taking place for years about the future of the municipal complex, which is located at 205 Claremont Avenue, 57 Park Street, and 68 North Fullerton Avenue. Some people have suggested renovating the building, and others want to move operations elsewhere.

One big factor? The potential value of the property, which is currently zoned for public uses only, officials say.

Find out what's happening in Montclairfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

A proposed redevelopment plan would have allowed for additional uses, such as multi-family homes, assisted living facilities, business offices, small cell wireless facilities, and “public utilities.”

The Montclair Town Council voted 5-2 to indefinitely table an ordinance that would have approved the plan at their Nov. 10 meeting, leaving the fate of the proposal uncertain.

Find out what's happening in Montclairfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

PSEG SUBSTATION

New Jersey’s largest electric and gas utility has been chiming in with a possible use for the property: use it to house a new electrical substation.

According to PSE&G, its existing substation at 60 Valley Road in Montclair is more than a century old and still contains original equipment. The substation serves nearly 9,000 customers, including 21 schools, five emergency facilities, 38 houses of worship and multiple township facilities.

Due to its age and deteriorating condition, the risk of equipment failure exceeds 50 percent, which has led to power outages in the past.

“Our outage data indicates several unplanned interruptions caused by aging equipment in the existing substation,” PSE&G reported in a FAQ sheet shared with the township.

“Failures are increasingly difficult to repair because replacement parts are hard to source,” the utility company continued. “Additionally, the current configuration and location of feeder electric lines limits PSE&G’s ability to reroute electricity during an outage, resulting in longer restoration times.”

An upgrade is urgently needed, the utility company says – and that’s where the town’s aging municipal building comes into the picture.

PSE&G pointed to an analysis of several potential options for where to place a new substation. The list included:

  • 651 and 665-679 Bloomfield Avenue
  • 33 Cottage Place (previously the site of Immaculate Conception High School
  • 233 Bloomfield Avenue
  • 6-10 Erie Street
  • 103 Grove Street
  • 101 Greenwood Avenue
  • Wildwood Avenue
  • 61-57 Valley Road and 46 Portland Place
  • 205 Claremont Avenue

It was this last option – the Montclair Municipal Building – that made the most sense, PSE&G’s analysis found:

“The municipal building property at 205 Claremont Avenue, including the bank parcel (57 Park St.) and the Cornerstone House parcel (68 North Fullerton Avenue) offers sufficient contiguous area to accommodate the new substation. Preliminary, non-invasive, subsurface utility investigations along Claremont Avenue, North Fullerton Avenue, and Park Street show comparatively lower underground utility congestion than the Valley Road / Portland Place location. This reduced utility congestion provides viable, technically efficient pathways for installing the required 26 kV and 4 kV infrastructure. The site’s close proximity to the existing Valley Road Substation also enables PSE&G to intercept and tie into existing 26 kV and 4 kV distribution circuits along their current routes. The combination of these more favorable conditions, and being in a redevelopment area, makes this site PSE&G’s preferred location for the new Montclair substation.”

PSE&G says it plans to minimize noise levels, build perimeter walls that “reflect neighborhood aesthetics,” and incorporate dark-sky lighting fixtures when possible.

According to PSE&G, the new station would replace the old facility on Valley Road, which will be kept running until construction of the new project is finished and all circuits are transferred.

The utility company gave a presentation about their proposal at the town council meeting on Oct. 20. Watch footage here or view it below (article continues underneath):

PUBLIC REACTION

The town’s now-tabled ordinance would have allowed the substation as a permitted use at the Municipal Building. However, it wouldn’t have given the project a final green light – that would have required further review.

Some Montclair residents have been determined not to let the proposal get that far.

Common complaints have included worries about the potential impact on the nearby residential neighborhood. Other critics have alleged that there has been a lack of transparency during the planning process.

Several people spoke against the proposal at the council meeting on Oct. 20, showing up carrying signs that read: “No Substation.”

“I have to tell you that none of the homeowners who live on Claremont with this proximity would ever have purchased a home on Claremont Avenue,” one resident said.

“A large electrical substation with industrial equipment, fencing, buzzing noises, bright lighting, video surveillance and heavy wiring would create an unwelcoming dead zone right in the middle of our walkable neighborhood,” another commenter said.

Another resident said the language of the ordinance could leave the door open to other “public utility” use – such as a data center.

The issue came up again last week, with several people speaking about the proposal during public comment (watch video footage here, or view it below).

While the council’s latest vote muddies up the water as far as the Municipal Building proposal, the need for more reliable energy in Montclair remains a problem in search of a solution.

A spokesperson for PSE&G told Montclair Local that the century-old substation on Valley Road still needs to be replaced to maintain reliable electric service and meet the community’s current and future energy needs.

“We look forward to continuing to work with the township and community to determine a path forward,” he said.

Mayor Renee Baskerville – who voted to table the redevelopment ordinance – said there are areas in town where it seems like “every time a hard wind blows they are without electricity.”

“We've looked at many, many places in the township,” she said at last week’s council meeting. “And I don't think anyone's going to just come forward and say yes, you know, in my backyard. But ultimately, I do believe we will have to make some very tough decisions.”

Send local news tips and correction requests to eric.kiefer@patch.com. Learn more about advertising on Patch here. Find out how to post announcements or events to your local Patch site.

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.