Toms River Attorney Who Stole From Boy Gets 26 Years In Prison

TRENTON, NJ – An attorney from Toms River who was convicted of stealing $1.5 million from five clients has been sentenced to 26 years in prison, state Attorney General Gurbir S. Grewal announced Thursday.

Joseph J. Talafous Jr., 55, of Toms River, who formerly practiced in Jersey City, was sentenced to state prison by Superior Court Judge Mirtha Ospina in Hudson County. He also was ordered to pay full restitution, Grewal's office said. Talafous had his license to practice law in New Jersey revoked in August 2015.

Talafous was convicted at trial in January in Hudson County on three second-degree counts of theft by unlawful taking, three second-degree counts of theft by failure to make required disposition of property received, four second-degree counts and one third-degree count of misapplication of entrusted property, one count each of second-degree and third-degree theft by deception, and four third-degree counts of filing fraudulent state income tax returns.

The state presented testimony and evidence at trial that Talafous committed the following thefts between October 2004 and May 2015 totaling approximately $1.5 million:

1. Talafous used a power of attorney to make unauthorized withdrawals of thousands of dollars from the investment account of an elderly client who lived in Jersey City and from the client’s estate after the client died in 2010.
2. Talafous stole approximately $461,000 from a trust set up for the benefit of a young boy in 2005 with funds from a wrongful death suit stemming from the death of his father. The father died in 2001 in a workplace accident when the child, a West New York resident, was still an infant.
3. Talafous stole approximately $300,000 from the estate of an elderly Jersey City woman who died in 2009 without any immediate family. She had hired him to prepare her will and had named him executor of her estate.
4. Talafous stole approximately $400,000 from the estate of a Jersey City man who died in 2012 and whose family hired Talafous as attorney for the estate, which included several life insurance policies worth a total of more than $870,000.
5. From 2012 to 2015, Talafous stole $330,000 that was entrusted to him as counsel for the estate of a Jersey City woman who owned property in New York.

Talafous failed to report the monies he allegedly misappropriated from his clients in state income tax returns that he filed for the tax years 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014.

Deputy Attorneys General Janet Bosi and Brandy Malfitano tried the case for the Division of Criminal Justice Financial & Computer Crimes Bureau, assisted by Detective Scott Stevens, Detective Roxanna Ordonez-Fresse, Detective Franco Cignarella, and Analyst Gaby Pichler. Sgt. James Scott, Lt. Vincent Gaeta, Deputy Chief of Detectives William Fredrick and former Bureau Chief Michael Monahan supervised the investigation and prosecution.

"Lawyers have a duty to uphold the law and defend the interests of their clients," Grewal said. "This prison sentence sends a strong message of deterrence that lawyers like Talafous who violate their duty and steal from their clients will be aggressively prosecuted."

"Talafous stole huge sums from multiple clients, but he revealed the true depth of his depravity when he stole nearly half a million dollars that had been placed in trust to provide for a child who lost his father," said Elie Honig, director of the Division of Criminal Justice.

Image via Shutterstock