Why Long Island Renters are Suddenly Moving to New Rochelle

New Rochelle is having a moment. Once a quiet suburb best known for its location just 17 miles north of Midtown Manhattan, this Westchester County city is quickly becoming a destination in its own right—particularly for renters looking to leave Long Island behind.

The reasons are stacking up. A revitalized downtown. A thriving arts and dining scene. Expansive waterfront parks. Direct access to Manhattan via the Metro-North New Haven Line, offering a fast, frequent, and stress-free alternative to the tiring and often costly drive Long Island renters face crossing bridges and tolls. And most importantly: a rental market that offers more value, style, and convenience than many Long Islanders are used to finding this close to New York City.

Among the newest communities turning heads is Westchester Place, a striking three-building development that blends upscale living with creativity and culture. Its final and most anticipated property, The Alary, just opened its doors, with first residents moving in this month. Long Island residents are choosing The Alary for its ability to easily reach Manhattan via Metro-North, eliminating the need for transfers and long drives. The Alary offers modern apartments, upscale amenities, and a vibrant downtown lifestyle that’s hard to find in Long Island’s aging rental market.

The brand-new 28-story tower features design-forward residences with skyline and Long Island Sound views, and upscale amenities like a rooftop pool, co-working lounges, 24/7 concierge service and smart home features throughout each residence, delivering a level of sophistication more often associated with luxury buildings in Manhattan or Brooklyn. Additional amenities include a 28th floor terrace.

Why the Move?

For many, New Rochelle offers the suburban character they love — tree-lined streets, quiet neighborhoods, parks and green space — but with city-style perks: walkable streets, great restaurants, and a direct, sub-40-minute train to Grand Central Terminal. It’s a lifestyle that appeals to professionals, creatives, and young families alike.

Long Islanders are noticing.

Susan Landaverry moved from Elmont to Westchester Place in New Rochelle after working locally for 10 years.

“I always heard and saw that the City of New Rochelle was investing in the community with events and artwork,” Ms. Landaverry said. “I particularly love living at Westchester Place because it's walking distance to the train, supermarket, pharmacy, and restaurants. I find New Rochelle to be the perfect mix of city life and the suburbs. It's perfect for my lifestyle.”

Mariela Nunez, a former East Meadow resident, moved to Westchester Place after originally planning to return to Queens, where she grew up. Rising rents and aging apartments made her look elsewhere.

“In Queens, you’re paying for location. Prices have increased since it’s so close to the city, but New Rochelle is also close to the city,” Ms. Nunez said. “I looked in New Rochelle and was able to find the perfect apartment with the perfect view. For the same price, you get a fully modernized, brand-new apartment that you know won’t give you any problems. The downtown is great and there are a lot of beautiful areas to explore, like parks and vintage mansions by the water.”

Looking Ahead

As more renters rethink their priorities amid evolving work and lifestyle trends, New Rochelle stands out as a smart, stylish, and vibrant alternative to Long Island.

For those relocating from Long Island, for a better quality of life, or seeking more space, The Alary’s location in New Rochelle offers the perfect blend of culture, convenience, and connectivity.