Traffic & Transit
NYC Subway Signal Upgrades Hit Major Delays
Delayed signal upgrades could mean more weekend service changes for riders.
NEW YORK CITY— The MTA faces delays in replacing aging subway signals with communications-based train control, a computerized system designed to let trains communicate with one another and run closer together.
Officials disclosed Monday that several major signal projects have fallen months behind schedule, pushing some expected launch dates into 2028.
The Fulton Street-Liberty Avenue project, covering portions of the A, C and E lines between 59th Street and High Street, has moved from the first quarter of 2027 to the fourth quarter of 2027.
Find out what's happening in New York Cityfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The Queens Boulevard Line East project, which upgrades signals on the F line between Union Turnpike and 179th Street, has shifted from the second quarter of 2027 to the second quarter of 2028.
The Crosstown project, covering the G and F lines between Court Square and Church Avenue, also faces delays. Both sections now have 2028 launch targets.
Find out what's happening in New York Cityfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The A and C line upgrade between Downtown Brooklyn and Ozone Park recently began and remains an exception to the delays.
Software problems, train compatibility issues and inaccurate track measurements have complicated the projects, according to MTA officials.
On the Eighth Avenue line, engineers discovered discrepancies between actual track conditions and measurements entered into the computerized signal system.
During testing, trains reported curves and hills that differed from the information programmed into the system.
Activating the technology before correcting those measurements could lead to repeated signal malfunctions.
The MTA experienced similar problems in 2022, when it activated the system on the Queens Boulevard West line. The rollout triggered as many as 20 signal malfunctions per day.
“We could turn this system on now, it’s ready to go,” Mark Roche, the MTA’s deputy chief development officer, told board members. “But you’d have lots of problems so we’re not gonna turn it on. On the QBL West we probably turned it on too soon, we’re not going to do that again.”
What Is Delaying The G Train Project?
The Crosstown project encountered unexpected tunnel damage and leaks, forcing the MTA to spend about a year making repairs before installing new signals.
The agency also abandoned an original plan to switch the entire line to the new system at once. Instead, engineers will divide the transition into five or six stages to allow more testing before activation.
The MTA has kept physical construction largely on schedule, including tunnel repairs, track work and infrastructure installation, according to MTA Construction and Development President Jamie Torres-Springer.
Will This Create Weekend Closures?
The delays could mean continued weekend service disruptions as the MTA works to install new signals, repair tunnels and test the computerized system.
However, officials have not announced additional weekend closures specifically tied to the revised project schedules.
The work may require temporary service changes while crews access tracks, replace equipment and test the new technology. Riders on the A, C, E, F and G lines could face future schedule changes as the projects progress.
Could Data Centers Increase Upgrade Costs?
The MTA has reduced signal upgrade costs by about 33 percent per mile on the Crosstown and Fulton Street-Liberty Avenue projects compared with several earlier projects.
But growing demand from data centers could threaten those savings.
Data centers, which support cloud computing and artificial intelligence services, compete with transportation agencies for cables and electronic equipment used in signal systems. Increased demand has driven up prices, Roche told board members.
“We are seeing a massive competition with data centers,” Roche said. “The cables, the equipment is getting more expensive. We have a huge competition on the market with data centers.”
How Much Money Is The City Cutting?
The MTA could face additional financial pressure as New York City reduces its contribution to bus operations by $200 million, leaving the agency to cover the difference.
Gov. Kathy Hochul’s administration agreed to the reduction as part of a broader effort to help New York City address its projected $6.2 billion budget deficit.
The change does not mean the MTA will immediately cut bus routes or service. Instead, the agency must absorb the lost city funding through its own resources.
The MTA’s July financial plan identifies the $200 million reduction as a one-time cut and says the agency has enough resources to maintain existing bus service. Hochul’s administration also maintains the arrangement will not affect riders.
But Reinvent Albany, a government watchdog group, argues the state has not fully replaced the missing money, leaving the MTA responsible for covering the shortfall.
“Unfortunately, the state has quietly chosen not to compensate MTA Bus, leaving the MTA – and ultimately bus riders – to eat the loss of city funding,” the group wrote in a statement Monday.
The funding reduction comes as the MTA projects a $295 million operating deficit in 2027, growing to nearly $900 million by 2030.
Hochul’s administration has defended its record of supporting public transportation, pointing to an increase in the payroll mobility tax on certain businesses to help finance the MTA after federal pandemic relief funding expired.
MTA officials are scheduled to update the agency’s financial projections Wednesday during its monthly board meeting.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.