How Walt Maddox Secured A Fifth Term Without A Runoff

TUSCALOOSA, AL — Despite the scrum of media surrounding Mayor Walt Maddox on Tuesday night, his victory declaration was fairly unceremonious as a heavy rain fell at the Tuscaloosa Amphitheater. Nonetheless, Maddox signaled an optimism for the future while also admitting that the campaign for his fifth term was the most difficult of his career.

As Maddox's next term in office is set to begin in May, here's a look at some of the reasons I believe he was able to claim outright victory in a three-candidate race without a runoff.

Want to show the love by supporting local journalism? Click here to help Tuscaloosa Patch keep growing for as little as $5 a month!

POLITICAL INEXPERIENCE OF OPPONENTS: While Maddox put on a clinic of political finesse running a re-election campaign during a pandemic, the overall dynamic likely did little to help his two opponents - former Alabama football player, pastor and radio personality Martin Houston and University of Alabama faculty member Serena Fortenberry. The campaigns were the first foray into politics for the challengers as they sought to unseat arguably the most popular mayor in the city's history other than the late Al DuPont. While I have no doubt either would do an acceptable job in the city's highest office, political acumen is something that's developed over time and only possible with direct exposure to the idiosyncrasies of daily bureaucracy. Maddox's experience, especially with lessons learned from the aftermath of the 2011 tornado, has served him well throughout the coronavirus pandemic and is a possible contributing factor to his surge in support on election night.

'THE STAN PATE EFFECT': I've covered more state and local elections than I can count, seeing numerous campaigns falter at the eleventh hour because of an itching desire to sling mud. While historical record will clearly show Stan Pate's longtime opposition of Maddox, I'm a big believer in a simple concept — you are more likely to put off undecided voters and drive them in the opposite direction if the only message they see is a negative one focusing on the candidate as a person and not the issues. Maddox maintained the high road on the campaign trail and there is no doubt some voters appreciated that, while others may have laughed at the signs, but still checked the box by Maddox's name. Look no further than the defeat of outspoken Pate ally Sonya McKinstry, who narrowly lost her re-election bid less than a week after standing alongside Pate for the demolition of the McFarland Mall.

MONEY: Deep pockets may not always win an election, but it certainly doesn't hurt. Maddox received $140,637 in cash contributions from August 2020 to February — coming in a little above the combined total fundraising for both of his challengers during that time. The exposure was also needed to counterbalance the visibility of businessman and longtime Maddox nemesis Stan Pate's "Anybody But Walt" campaign, which saw thousands of dollars spent on billboards and advertising in an effort to unseat the incumbent.

WATCH MADDOX'S FULL VICTORY SPEECH BELOW

EXPOSURE: Maddox is a media-savvy mayor and one who has proven himself effective in utilizing multiple platforms to communicate his message. Now entering a fifth term as mayor and not counting his time as the councilman for District 6, his name has become synonymous with the office, as many locals of all political stripes refer to him simply as "Walt." Three public political debates also helped Maddox set himself apart from his opponents, while providing a stage for him to cite his accomplishments and an intention to build on longterm goals. In my opinion, his presentation at the debates reinforced the public perception that he was the frontrunner, thus galvanizing his base to get out and vote, while also possibly keeping some opposition voters from leaving the house on election day. Each individual has their own reasons for voting for candidates, but it was clear from the beginning that it was Maddox's race to lose. Once that narrative was set early on, a protracted campaign leading to a runoff became that much more unlikely for either of his opponents.

RECORD: Whether you love the man or hate him, you have to admit that Maddox has led the city through not one, but two major crises with the 2011 tornado and coronavirus pandemic. Both of these deadly events saw policy born of necessity, while Maddox managed the balancing act of protecting public health and preserving the city's economy. Numerous times detractors have vocally opposed Maddox's approach to these events, but it's tough to argue that the recovery zone from the tornado did not come back better than it had ever been and the city's economic position is drastically improved from the sharp downturn during the pandemic. I think at the end of the day, the majority of voters wanted a familiar face during uncertain times and it showed once the final ballots were tallied. And while there were controversies along the way, especially regarding the build up to a glut of student housing and the city's lax enforcement of coronavirus guidelines for large gatherings, the improved public health and economic situations at present likely made it easier for voters to stick with the incumbent.

RAIN ON ELECTION DAY: I always joke that election outcomes can be swayed by the weather, so who knows? Maybe the rain showers and cold temperatures lasting all day played some kind of contributing factor to the 20% voter turnout. But with the wide-margin of victory, I highly doubt the outcome would have been much different on a sunny, 70-degree March day.

About me: I grew up in Tuscaloosa and graduated from the University of Alabama's community journalism master's program, going on to work for the Starkville Daily News, Weather.com, Associated Press, the Birmingham Business Journal and the Anniston Star before founding the Tuscaloosa Patch. You can find me at public meetings, Alabama sporting events and wherever live music is played!