Crime & Safety
Drew Peterson Case Hits Appellate Court -- Lawyer Says 'Boneheaded' Move Should Trigger New Trial
Drew Peterson's attorney said the lead lawyer for his murder trial did such a bad job the wife-killer needs another day in court.

Nearly three years after a jury found him guilty of drowning his estranged third wife, an attorney for disgraced Bolingbrook cop Drew Peterson made his case to get a new trial.
Steve Greenberg, who was among the half-dozen attorneys defending Peterson at his 2012 murder trial, argued in front of three appellate judges Thursday morning. Greenberg appeared with yet another addition to Petersonβs legal stable β Harold Krent, a dean and professor at Chicago-Kent College of Law.
Greenberg argued that Petersonβs former lead attorney, Joel Brodsky, was ineffective. Krent claimed 10 hearsay statements introduced at trial should never have been allowed as evidence.
Find out what's happening in Bolingbrookfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Brodsky and Peterson, along with a Florida-based publicist, entered into a media contract soon after the disappearance of Petersonβs fourth wife, Stacy Peterson, in October 2007, Greenberg said. He argued that the ill-conceived idea to make money and gain fame was improper and against Petersonβs self-interest.
Greenberg also criticized Brodskyβs decision to call Savioβs divorce attorney, Harry Smith, to the witness stand. Brodsky had apparently hoped Smithβs testimony would sully Stacyβs character. Instead, Smith repeatedly hammered home to the jury that Stacy told him Peterson killed Savio. Jurors later said Smithβs testimony clinched the guilty verdict.
Find out what's happening in Bolingbrookfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
βIt was so frankly boneheaded to do,β Greenberg said of Brodskyβs trial strategy.
Assistant Stateβs Attorney Marie Czech countered that it was actually Petersonβs idea to call Smith as a witness. After the hearing, Greenberg said that was not the case.
βI donβt know where they get that from,β he said.
βA client doesnβt decide who to call as a witness,β Greenberg said. βThe lawyer decides who to call as a witness. Drew Peterson didnβt come into the courtroom and say, βIβm calling Mr. Smith as a witness.β I donβt know where they get that from.β
Greenberg has long blamed Brodsky for losing the case, calling him, among other things, a βstumbling,β βditheringβ liar.
The appellate judges have yet to decide whether Peterson, 61, will get a new trial.
Peterson was sentenced to 38 years in prison and has been locked up at downstate Menard Correctional Center since February 2013.
Petersonβs slain third wife, Kathleen Savio, turned up drowned in a dry bathtub in March 2004. Savio, 40, and Peterson, a Bolingbrook police sergeant, were in the midst of a contentious divorce when she mysteriously happened to die, but investigators from the Illinois State Police found nothing suspicious about the matter and quickly decided she was merely the unlucky victim of a freak bathtub accident.
Savioβs death was quickly forgotten but leapt into the national consciousness when Stacy vanished. The state police named Drew Peterson a suspect in Stacyβs βpotential homicideβ but have never gotten around to charging him with harming her.
Even if he were to triumph in his appeal, Peterson faces new charges of solicitation of murder for hire and solicitation of murder. According to a criminal complaint, Peterson βprocuredβ an unnamed person to βfind another to killβ Will County Stateβs Attorney James Glasgow, the prosecutor who secured the murder conviction in the Savio case. Peterson is scheduled to appear in Randolph County court Friday for his murder-for-hire case.
Go take a look at our Facebook page.
And make sure you read all of these other fantastic stories:
- Wanted Ex-Con Armed With BB Gun Failed in Flight From Joliet Cops: Police
- Bad Kitty! Tinley Park Man Calls Cops on Cat That Attacked Him and His 70-Pound Lab
- Frankfort Woman Wore 3 Stolen Bras and Earrings Out of Tinley Park Kohlβs: Cops