Compare & Contrast: Granite and Marble Countertops

Today we’re going to compare two of the most stylish and common countertops in the kitchen and bath market.  Since granite is by far the most common type of countertop installed these days, we’ve decided to explain the difference between granite and marble stone (which is another popular choice).

Similarities

But first, it makes more sense to explain the similarities.  They are both stone, which makes them hard, heavy, and more valuable than other countertop options. They are both natural products, meaning there will be variations in color and pattern from one slab to the next.  So when you go look at sample pieces for both granite and marble, there’s a strong chance that when you’re specific piece is delivered, it’s far from identical to the pattern you saw at the showroom or store. 

Both materials can get stained by oily foods that are left unattended for a long period of time.  Because of this, both require resealing every so often.  To add another positive, both materials are relatively heatproof, and they won't scorch or leave a ring.  Depending on the situation, it’s been suggested that a scolding hot pot placed directly on either type of stone could cause a crack, but this is extremely rare to happen to a quality piece.  This scenario can easily be avoided by placing a dish towel over the counter to limit the heat on the surface.  

Finally, both start at about $60 per square foot installed, but granite prices can actually be as high as $200 per square foot too.  So it’s certainly incorrect to assume all granite is in the same price range when planning a kitchen.

Differences

While both stones are relatively firm materials, granite is a much harder, stronger stone than marble.  It resists chipping and scratching better, and it’s resistant to acids like juice or vinegar.  Marble is a calcium carbonate, similar to chalk, but in a compressed and crystallized form.  So the surface of a marble countertop can be etched or scratched permanently.  Scratches and cracks will probably also be more visible on marble too.  Some marble slabs have very little pattern, or no pattern at all so it’s no wonder that stains will be more noticeable.  Granite typically has a complex mottled pattern that hides stains better.  This begins to explain why for so many homeowners, granite is simply the better choice.  But on the flip side, if you’re a homeowner that takes care of their furniture and doesn’t mind some maintenance, marble could be just the countertop for you!

Marble does have an appealing look for many homeowners.  Many believe that marble is a more elegant, luxurious and classy alternative to granite.  It has extremely fine crystals, which create a snowy or satin themed appearance.  The natural patterns on the stone can be quite sharp.  Granite tends to have larger crystals which gives off a more coarse and sparkly appearance.  Also, while granite comes in a range of colors and patterns, marble countertops have considerably less options to choose from.  Having less choices in marble may actually help create the luxurious and coveted public opinion of it.  So pattern choices alone shouldn’t deter you from marble because the pattern you’re looking for may still be offered.

To conclude, most people seem to favor granite for heavy use areas like countertops.  Marble requires maintenance, less durable and about as expensive. Its one advantage may be in appearance, but that obviously depends on the personal preference of the homeowner.   Both options have reason to like them, and reasons to reconsider.  When planning a room as important as your home’s kitchen, be sure to thoroughly go through all of your options and consider your budget before coming to a conclusion.

Good luck with your search and as always, NDA Kitchens is here to help.  Don’t hesitate to give our showroom a call at 631 360-3818, or conveniently email us at info@ndakitchensandconstruction.com.