Politics & Government
Fairfax Board Votes 6-4 On Flock Camera Restrictions, Vendor Change
Fairfax supervisors voted 6-4 to tighten Flock camera privacy rules, limit data retention and begin transitioning to another vendor.
FAIRFAX COUNTY, VA — The Fairfax County Board of Supervisors voted 6-4 Tuesday to impose stricter privacy protections on the county's automated license plate reader program, continue a freeze on installing additional Flock Safety cameras and begin transitioning away from the controversial surveillance technology.
The board approved a motion introduced by Chairman Jeff McKay (D-At-Large) that would reduce how long police retain license plate data, restrict who can search the database and prohibit sharing information with other law enforcement agencies except under specified circumstances. The measure also calls for moving the data to county-controlled servers and evaluating alternative camera vendors.
Supervisors Rachna Sizemore-Heizer (D-Braddock), Dalia Palchik (D-Providence), Jimmie Bierman (D-Dranesville) and Andres Jimenez (D-Mason) opposed the measure. Patch has reached out to each of the supervisors for commen.
Find out what's happening in McLeanfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Fairfax County Moves To Strengthen Privacy Protections
Tuesday's action follows a Sept. 15 board decision to pause the expansion of stationary Flock Safety automated license plate readers, commonly known as ALPRs, amid concerns about how the technology collects, stores and shares information about motorists.
In his board matter, McKay said the county sought answers from Flock Safety after reports surfaced elsewhere in the country about improper and unethical use of license plate data by people with access to the technology.
Find out what's happening in McLeanfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Although the company responded to questions submitted by the county, McKay said its answers did not resolve many of the concerns.
Also See ...
- Fairfax Pauses Flock Camera Expansion As Arlington Ends Its Program
- Arlington County Board Orders End To Flock Camera Use
- McDaniel Seeks Flock Camera Ban On Fairfax School Property; DeFlock Fairfax Backs Motion
The Fairfax County Police Department subsequently presented information about the program during an Oct. 20 meeting of the board's Safety and Security Committee.
McKay acknowledged that police have demonstrated responsible use of the technology, including oversight of data retention, sharing, searches and auditing. He also recognized the cameras' value as a public safety tool.
However, he said additional restrictions were necessary to maintain community confidence in the program.
"We also recognize that for any public safety effort to be effective, there needs to be trust from our community and that our program must evolve to ensure that trust is maintained," McKay wrote in the board matter.
The chairman said the changes are intended to strengthen privacy protections while preserving the technology's legitimate investigative capabilities.
What The New Flock Camera Restrictions Would Do
Under the approved motion, county officials and the Fairfax County Police Department are directed to establish stricter guidelines for the program.
The changes include:
- Camera expansion: Continue the prohibition on installing additional stationary Flock Safety cameras, consistent with the board's Sept. 15 action.
- Data retention: Limit the retention of automated license plate reader data to seven days.
- Database access: Restrict searches to officers specifically assigned to the police department's Real Time Crime Center, which has approximately 50 sworn officers.
- Information sharing: Prohibit sharing ALPR data with other law enforcement agencies, unless required by law, until a regional sharing framework is developed through the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments.
- County-controlled storage: Begin transferring data from the county's Amazon Web Services cloud environment to servers owned and operated by Fairfax County at the Government Center or another county facility.
- Vendor access: Ensure Flock Safety does not manage or have access to data collected by county-operated cameras.
- Auditing: Establish additional auditing standards for the revised system.
- Transparency: Publicly disclose camera locations and the criteria used to determine where cameras are installed.
- Alternative technology: Continue evaluating other ALPR vendors and work toward transitioning away from Flock Safety.
The county also plans to publish its guidelines and encourage private owners of license plate reader cameras to adopt similar privacy protections voluntarily.
McKay's motion acknowledges that the county lacks designated legal authority to regulate ALPR equipment it does not own.
The changes apply to stationary Flock Safety cameras operated by or accessible to Fairfax County police.
County officials are scheduled to report on their progress at a special Safety and Security Committee meeting on Dec. 15 at 1:30 p.m., including timelines for implementing any outstanding requirements.
Police Credit License Plate Readers With Burglary Arrest
The debate over Flock cameras comes as Fairfax County police continue to credit automated license plate readers with helping investigators solve crimes.
In an Oct. 29 news release, police described how ALPR technology helped detectives locate and arrest a burglary suspect two days earlier.
Officers responded to a home in the 8900 block of Karen Drive in Mantua on Oct. 27 after a homeowner spotted someone breaking into the residence through a security camera. The homeowner provided investigators with a description of the suspect and his vehicle.
Detectives assigned to the Real Time Crime Center and the Auto Crime Enforcement Squad used license plate reader technology to locate the vehicle on Richmond Highway in Fair Haven, according to police.
Officers arrested Michael Spillino, 73, of Alexandria, and recovered evidence they said connected him to additional burglaries outside Fairfax County.
Spillino was charged with burglary and grand larceny and later released on a $2,000 bond.
Police credited the technology and coordination between detective units with helping them quickly identify and locate the suspect.
Arlington Ends Flock Program As Fairfax Weighs Alternatives
Fairfax County's decision contrasts with the approach taken by neighboring Arlington County, which directed officials in September to stop using county-leased Flock Safety technology and begin removing 41 cameras.
The Arlington County Board's Sept. 15 directive covered 26 Falcon license plate readers and 15 Condor cameras. The county also ordered the deletion of data not required for active criminal investigations, subject to applicable requirements.
Arlington County Board Chair Matt de Ferranti said the decision reflected residents' concerns about the technology, even though county officials had reported no misuse of the system.
Privately owned cameras were not affected by Arlington's directive.
In Fairfax County, the September decision to halt expansion left 84 licensed stationary Flock cameras operating. The county's previous guidelines called for deleting data after 21 days, compared with the seven-day limit included in Tuesday's motion.
The controversy has also reached Fairfax County Public Schools.
In September, at-large School Board member Kyle McDaniel proposed prohibiting Flock cameras on school property, arguing that the school system should not expand into broader surveillance activities. His proposal included exceptions for school bus stop-arm cameras and school-zone speed cameras.
The advocacy group DeFlock Fairfax endorsed McDaniel's proposal and called for a broader prohibition on automated license plate readers throughout the county.
The group previously criticized the supervisors' September decision to pause expansion rather than eliminate the technology.
Unlike Arlington's decision to end its county-leased Flock program, Fairfax County's latest action allows its existing cameras to remain in operation while officials implement additional safeguards and evaluate replacements.
The Dec. 15 committee meeting will provide the next opportunity for supervisors to review progress toward the new restrictions and the transition away from Flock Safety.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.