Home & Garden
Military Plane, Helicopters Circle Manhattan: Nothing to See Here, Government Says
UPDATES: Just some "standard military training" over America's largest city on a Tuesday afternoon, according to a guy named Col. Broccoli.
UPDATE, Tuesday, 8:20 p.m.: While the Air National Guard keeps insisting Tuesday's Midtown flyover was a "routine training flight," CBS news radio reporter Alex Silverman says he has a government source telling him the military aircrafts were "involved in a Secret Service protective operation... coordinated with the FAA."
Representatives for both the U.S. Secret Service and the FAA did not answer Patch's requests for comment on this development Tuesday night.
One odd aspect of the case, though: NYC Emergency Management, the agency that sends out alerts to New Yorkers whenever there's a potentially alarming event (such as a military flyover) on the horizon, "did not have any information about this flyover before it happened," according to spokeswoman Nancy Silvestri.
Find out what's happening in New York Cityfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
"We have a standard routine" with the FAA, the city spokeswoman said, and "it's rare that it's not followed. So I'm not really sure what was the problem."
(In case you've been living under a rock: U.S. President-elect Donald Trump currently resides inside an ornate, gold-plated penthouse at the top of Trump Tower, located along 5th Avenue between East 56th and East 57th streets in Midtown. The FAA established a no-fly zone in the 3,000 feet above the tower back in November, as soon as Trump was elected — although that hasn't done much to ease pedestrian and vehicular chaos at street level.)
Find out what's happening in New York Cityfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Reached again Tuesday night by phone (previous convo below), Eric Durr, a spokesman for the Air National Guard, said: "All I can tell you is the aircraft belonged to the 106th Rescue Wing, and it was a training mission." He said the plane's pilot, the now-famous Col. Broccoli — "a good guy and a pretty experienced aviator" — informed his superiors, as per protocol, that he wanted to schedule a training mission over Manhattan on Tuesday, to which his superiors answered, "OK, it's scheduled."
Durr said he had "no clue" how the Secret Service would have gone about combining its own operation with Broccoli's training flight. "I don't even know how that happens," he said.
Prominent aviation blogger Jason Rabinowitz counts himself among Col. Broccoli's skeptics. From his Twitter timeline:
No idea what that C-130 was doing circling so low over Manhattan, but it’s hard not to imagine it has something to do with Trump Tower. https://t.co/y2Jl5lSQAz
— Jason Rabinowitz (@AirlineFlyer) December 13, 2016
And for anyone doubting the data that it really was a C-130 orbiting low and slow over Manhattan, here it is. https://t.co/tU0GbAlFGC
— Jason Rabinowitz (@AirlineFlyer) December 13, 2016
Ain’t nothing standard about a C-130 orbiting Manhattan at 3,000 feet, Col. Broccoli. https://t.co/3BMyOCrFzF
— Jason Rabinowitz (@AirlineFlyer) December 13, 2016
Stay tuned for additional updates as they come in. Our original story, posted around 5:30 p.m. Tuesday, is below.
MANHATTAN, NY — A military plane and a couple Black Hawk helicopters spotted weaving through the skies over Manhattan early Tuesday evening, sending city dwellers into something of a tither, were in fact "authorized flights over New York City in coordination with FAA air traffic control," according to an FAA spokeswoman.
Col. Nicholas Broccoli — yes, Broccoli — told a Washington Post reporter that the extended flyover was part of "standard military training."
Col. Broccoli, CO of the 106th Rescue Wing says the C130 circling Manhattan is doing "standard military training."
— Thomas Gibbons-Neff (@Tmgneff) December 13, 2016
Eric Durr, a spokesman for the Air National Guard, identified the aircrafts as an HC-130 Hercules plane, used for search and rescue, and two HH-60 Pave Hawk helicopters, "a version of the Black Hawk also used for search and rescue." They were launched Tuesday from the 106th Rescue Wing of the Francis S. Gabreski Air National Guard Base on Long Island, he said.
Want more local news? Sign up here for daily newsletters and news alerts from your neighborhood Patch site in NYC.
"It was a routine training flight," Durr said. "We do this all the time."
The military aircrafts were first spotted around 4 p.m. Tuesday. Footage from freaked-out witnesses flooded social media for the next half hour or so.
A video of the plane that's been circling Manhattan pic.twitter.com/Bsj5ANEeW1
— Alp Ozcelik (@alplicable) December 13, 2016
C130 and 2 Appachie Helicopters circling Manhattan right now pic.twitter.com/Ikb2YNv4QJ
— Jason Hart (@jayphart) December 13, 2016
Why is this plane circulating so low in Manhattan?! It brings back bad memories:( @CNN pic.twitter.com/Y11GcISeqp
— Erdal Kuyumcu (@Erdalkuyumcu) December 13, 2016
What's happening? I was asking myself the same thing! Military looking plane circling Manhattan?! pic.twitter.com/0D5HKYNGHj
— elvan (@islandLostFound) December 13, 2016
Anybody know about the #plane circling #Manhattan right now? @NYPDnews @BilldeBlasio pic.twitter.com/3Men3dJF7z
— The Community NYC (@TheCommunityNYC) December 13, 2016
Contacted by a flurry of reporters, NYPD spokespeople originally said they had no idea why a warplane was circling Manhattan on a Tuesday afternoon.
Finally, at 4:37 p.m., Col. Broccoli spoke — and the city breathed a collective sigh of relief. Sort of.
REPORTER: How should I attribute this statement? LYING GOVERNMENT, LOOKING AT LUNCH LEFTOVERS: To Colonel....uhh......Colonel Broccoli https://t.co/5MlsAaFgmw
— Brendan O'Connor (@_grendan) December 13, 2016
Lead image via Chris Gettings/Twitter
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.