Civil Service Commission Appointment Criticized By Yardley Applicant

YARDLEY, PA —While the Borough Council filled a vacancy on its Civil Service Commission, one resident felt that she was passed over for the position even though she had previously applied for the post.

In a unanimous vote, the Borough Council appointed Scott Staropoli as an alternate to the Civil Service Commission with the term ending on Dec. 31, 2027.

The council also appointed Samantha Willinger to the Parks and Recreation Board with the term ending on Dec. 31, 2024.

Both vacancies were filled during the council's meeting last week to the satisfaction of Council President Caroline Thompson.

"We've had vacancies open for years," she said.

But Dawn Perlmutter —a resident who appears at most council meetings questioning and challenging borough spending, policies, and procedures —said she had applied for the opening and was wondering why no one interviewed her.

"I was handed two applications," said Councilman David Appelbaum, who vetted the candidates by reviewing their resumes and references. "I wasn't made aware of yours."

Perlmutter questioned why a six-year position was never publicized on an email blast, social media, or the borough's website.

"My application was actively in the file," she said. "I have over 20 years of experience in law enforcement. I don't know why I wasn't part of this process."

Thompson said that prior applicants do not get re-interviewed for borough vacancies.

The Civil Service Commission presents applicants for police officers to the Borough Council for consideration. An alternate serves to replace a commission member if necessary.

Perlmutter requested that the council table the vote until all applicants are interviewed.

The council instead approved the appointments in a 7-0 vote.