A 4-year-old who falls asleep twirling the same lock of hair every night may have a thing or two to say about what happens to it in the stylist's chair.
How much say should a child that young have in how their hair is cut or styled? We asked readers about that for The Question, Patch's exclusive etiquette and ethics column.
The informal survey was prompted by Reddit discussion about a mom who backed her son's desire for a ponytail, but his dad cut his hair anyway, and his grandmother said he looked "neglected" as he grew it back. Commenters largely sided with the mom, and several said they'd heard the same complaints about their own sons' long hair.
Parents responding to the informal Patch survey generally said kids should have agency over their hair, even as young toddlers. But they split over whether the child's choice should stick when a parent hates it. Almost everyone said grandparents should stay out of it.
There were exceptions.
Parents can discuss it with their children and perhaps find a compromise everyone's happy with, but parents have veto power, said Minneapolis Patch reader Lee.
"Parents have the final say. Grandparents can comment to parents, but it is not their choice," Lee said. "While a child lives at home and is under 18, parents can express their disapproval if it is unacceptable, but hopefully, they can agree to something."
Decatur-Avondale (Georgia) Patch reader Tonya said 4-year-olds are too young to make decisions about their hair that could cause their peers to ostracize them. Parents can save them from that by withholding the choice, she said.
"Get a fun wig to play with, but avoid any chance for abuse from peers," Tonya said.
East Brunswick (New Jersey) Patch reader Eileen thinks 4 is "definitely too young." She said parents should discuss the pros and cons of the style or cut but take the final decision out of their hands.
"If a 4-year-old even cares about his hair, it's important to him. Give him options and let him choose," said Stonington-Mystic (Connecticut) Patch reader CB. "Parents should help children feel confident about their choices. It will build confidence."
But at the same time, "parents should always have veto power until the child is old enough to choose for himself, probably 'tween," CB said
St. Charles (Illinois) Patch reader Kathy wishes she'd had any kind of say in her hairstyle as a kid.
"My mother was a stylist, and she whacked off my hair in a bowl cut until I started high school. She loved short hair, and I hated it. I still cringe if I see a kid with that sickening cut," Kathy said.
It's normal for kids to try new styles as they grow up, Kathy said.
"Adults should support children," she said. "Stop making every decision for them. Too many 'kids' now in their 40s and beyond aren't mature enough to make their own decisions about anything!"
Elmhurst (Illinois) Patch reader Beverly said kids should decide for themselves after a thoughtful discussion with their parents.
"Parents should help the child navigate their choices and explain that others may be judgmental but support the child's decision," Beverly said. "They need to experience their decision-making power."
"I let my daughter make the call for very short hair when she was 6 and regret nothing, five years later," Vienna (Virginia) Patch reader Susan said. "She is very expressive with her appearance, and I continue to want to encourage her to be. I would have let her cut her hair short younger, if the idea had occurred to her."
Randolph (New Jersey) Patch reader Mary said her sons, now 31 and 38, always had control over their hair.
"We went through many colors and styles, and they grew confident and successful," she said. "There are so many things in a child's life where a parent must take control, but their hair isn't one of them."
When one of her sons was a ring bearer in a wedding, Mary asked if he'd agree to have his hair styled for the wedding and then let it grow out.
"He complied, no problem," she said.
Wilmette-Kenilworth (Illinois) Patch reader Ann said empowering kids with decisions about their hair gives them more confidence.
"You do not have to like it; you simply need to love them," she said. "Allow them to feel safe with you."
That's only possible if adults avoid disagreeing about it in the child's presence, she said.
"The child should not be subjected to family pressure regarding the matter," Ann said. "They will encounter enough of this inappropriate behavior later in life. The family should love them unconditionally for who they are."
Children are never too young to start expressing autonomy over their bodies, several readers said.
Glendale (Wisconsin) Patch reader Kristine, who has been cutting and styling other people's hair for 42 years, said she has encountered the push-and-pull between parents and children "more times than I can enumerate."
"My father was a 'greaser' in the '50s. He's 85 now and still likes to wear his hair longer," she said. "Every generation goes through these hair battles."
And it's not worth a fuss, she said.
"It's just hair. It grows. It can be colored. It will grow out," Kristine said. "Building a child's confidence and trust will last their lifetime."
While potential negative attention from unconventional hairstyles shouldn't be completely ignored, Kristine noted that parents shouldn't place undue emphasis on it either.
"Bullying is always a concern when it comes to children," she said. "But if they have the confidence to stand up for themselves, or if they are so emotionally mature that they don't allow what others think to define who they are, then how they wear their hair should be the least of everyone's worries."
"The kid will adjust their desires on their own if they're being teased or bullied," North Andover (Massachusetts) Patch reader Mae said. "Parents should support the child in experimenting and reversing course as needed."
Junie, a Woodbury (Minnesota) Patch reader, said that, "at the bare minimum," parents should talk with their kids about the possibility they may be teased or bullied over their hair choices.
"Kids can be mean and cruel when someone chooses something different," she said. "Unfortunately, a lot of [people] who say 'let them eat cake' don't have kids and don't understand just how mean kids are nowadays, even with anti-bullying campaigns."
Junie said she's talked to adults in both situations — those who look back on their childhood years and are grateful their parents told them no, and those who wish in retrospect that their parents had.
All that said, "If the child still wants to do it and has the confidence to rock it, that's fine."
Whatever a kid's hairstyle, whether it's one with deep cultural significance or like one they saw on TikTok, it's a good chance to teach respect, said New York City Patch reader Dee.
"We should teach our children to be tolerant of differences, interested in the differently abled, and encouraged to think outside the box," Dee said. "We should not teach them to feel afraid if they are a little different inside or out."
Fiona, a Wheaton (Illinois) Patch reader, said "any age is good" for kids to call the shots about their hair.
"Kids have so few things in life they can control. Let them do this while they're young enough that it won't affect job offers," she said.
A parent's job is to help their kids feel confident in their choices, she said, "with no 'I told you so' if they change their minds, for whatever reason."
Mary, an Ocean City (New Jersey) Patch reader, said letting kids choose their hairstyle at a young age is "an excellent opportunity to teach hair care."
"It's hair. It's not permanent like a tattoo," Mary said. "The same boy who wants a ponytail at 5 might want a buzz cut at 8."
Sign up for free local newsletters and alerts for the
Across America Patch
Patch.com is the nationwide leader in hyperlocal news.
Visit Patch.com to find your town today.