How Young Is Too Young For Kids To Choose Their Own Haircuts And Styles? [The Question]

It’s the kid’s hair, right? If he wants to grow a ponytail or she wants a buzz cut like Sinéad O’Connor, it’s their business, right?

Does it matter if the child is 4?

It does not, according to a recent discussion on Reddit started by a mom of a 4-year-old absolutely committed to growing a ponytail. She supports it. Dad initially wasn’t going for it and cut his hair, a setback, but not enough to break his resolve. He’s coming around and has stopped making negative remarks because he knows it means so much to his son.

His dark blonde locks — which his mom describes as “gorgeous” and potentially curly — frequently draw comments, but the boy handles them with ease. Confident and unapologetic, he advocates for himself by explaining that he is growing out his hair.

The “worst offender” is the child’s grandmother. She won’t let it go.

“She says he looks neglected. … That is a ridiculous word to use,” the woman wrote. “Does anyone have a similar experience? Did it get better with time? I’m emotionally exhausted by the comments, which feel sexist in a weird way.”

Commenters largely sided with the mom. Many had fielded similar complaints about their own sons’ long hair, framing it as a matter of bodily autonomy, with several criticizing adults’ expectations that boys should have short hair.

One mother said her 3-year-old son has never had a haircut and has made it clear he likes his long hair. She’s frustrated that even her otherwise open-minded husband insists the boy needs a haircut, arguing he wouldn’t say the same thing if their child were a girl. To her, it’s an exhausting example of how deeply ingrained gender stereotypes remain.

It’s not just the haircut. Hair color came up, too. One mother said her 14-year-old son, who also has long hair, jokingly suggested the 4-year-old dye his hair to further annoy his grandparents, who were already rattled by his sister’s bright pink locks. The original poster said her son would love that. Another parent said her nearly 11-year-old son, who had worn his hair long until age 6, now wants to color it, and she plans to let him.

For these parents, letting kids experiment with their appearance is part of giving them room to express themselves.

Child-development experts say that’s healthy and that children should choose their haircuts and clothing early — by elementary school at least — to build confidence and judgment.

The Child Mind Institute advises offering toddlers acceptable style choices, gradually expanding their independence as they show responsibility. A study in Child Development said kids gain autonomy first in personal preferences like hairstyles and clothing, while parents retain authority over health and safety decisions.

But where should adults draw the line, if at all?

At what age should children get the final say over their haircuts, hairstyles and personal appearance? Is 4 too young to make those decisions, or old enough to know what they like?

And who gets the final say when adults disagree? Should parents have veto power over a child’s hairstyle? Do grandparents get a vote, or should they keep their opinions to themselves?

What if a child wants a hairstyle that others might find unusual? Are concerns about teasing or bullying legitimate reasons to intervene, or should adults help children feel confident about their choices?

We’re asking for The Question, Patch’s exclusive etiquette and ethics column. Just fill out the survey below. As always, we don’t collect email addresses.

About The Question

The Question is an exclusive Patch column on etiquette, everyday ethics and what to do when the rules aren't quite as clear as everyone pretends they are — and readers provide the answers. If you have a topic you'd like us to consider, email beth.dalbey@patch.com with “The Question” as the subject line.

Catch Up On The Question

• Babysitting Or Child Neglect? Readers Weigh In On Mom’s Arrest
• Taking Your Pooch Everywhere Can Cross Line Even Dog Owners Draw
• Coffee Shop ‘Laptop Squatters’ Can Overstay Their Welcome
• Take Off Your Shoes, But Don’t Make Guests Bare Their Soles