Daniel Cochrane and Jack Fitzhenry on 'Senate’s Rebranded AI Moratorium Is Fatally Flawed'

According to the Daily Signal: "Daniel Cochrane is a senior research associate for the Tech Policy Center at The Heritage Foundation." Also per the Daily Signal: "Jack Fitzhenry is a legal fellow in The Heritage Foundation's Meese Center for Legal and Judicial Studies." Cochrane and Fitzhenry provided the commentary via the Daily Signal to this writer for MHProNews and the "Reality Check" series for this Patch. Part II provides additional insights plus other topics.

Part I

Commentary
Senate’s Rebranded AI Moratorium Is Fatally Flawed

On Saturday, the U.S. Senate parliamentarian cleared a proposed measure discouraging states from placing safeguards on artificial intelligence and Big Tech for the next decade. It could be included in the reconciliation package that the Senate is expected to consider as early as this week.

To overcome the Senate’s arcane rules, the Commerce Committee rewrote a House-passed version of the measure to condition $500 million for AI projects on states’ compliance with the moratorium.
But the measure goes further by creating triggers that would enable the Department of Commerce to “deobligate” additional broadband dollars already promised to states if they don’t stand-down.

Branded a 10-year “temporary pause” on state AI rules, this approach remains deeply flawed. Not only would it fail to rein-in California’s woke AI overreach and jeopardize broadband funds for conservative states and rural communities—it also poses concerns for state sovereignty.

Once a state is subject to the moratorium, they risk losing the ability to enforce laws related to everything from kids’ online safety and data privacy to safeguards on mental health chatbots.

Under the measure, if even one dollar of Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment—or BEAD—funding is “obligated” to a state or locality on or after enactment, it becomes subject to the moratorium per subsection (q).

Here’s the kicker. Once a state triggers subsection (q), it cannot enforce any law that even arguably violates the moratorium without running the risk of losing all BEAD funding—much of the $42.5 billion provisionally approved.

That’s because Commerce can claw back BEAD funding previously obligated under subsection (g)(3)(B)(iii) of the measure, which authorizes them to “deobligate grant funds awarded to an eligible entity that” is not in compliance with subsection (q).

According to researchers at the Institute for Law and AI, “[t]his deobligation provision clearly and unambiguously applies to all $42.45 billion in previously obligated BEAD funding, in addition to the new $500 million.”

Proponents stress that the conditions only apply if states opt to draw from the new $500 million dollar pool.

But it’s more complicated.

As the Institute for Law and AI points out, Commerce could deobligate previously obligated funds for reasons such as “an insufficient level of performance, or wasteful or fraudulent spending.” But then “re-obligation of the clawed-back funds would require compliance with the moratorium.”

Since Commerce changed the Biden-era guidance for BEAD grantees and is prompting states to request amendments to their award agreements, it seems at least conceivable that much of the $42.5 billion could technically be re-obligated.

At that point, states have a choice. Risk potentially forfeiting BEAD dollars already promised, or stop enforcing laws on AI and Big Tech.

Smaller conservative states with limited budgets and large rural populations need these funds. But wealthy progressive states like California and New York can afford to take a pass and just keep enforcing their tech laws.

That’s a fatal flaw.

Proponents of the moratorium have largely staked their case on preventing California and New York from imposing European-style AI regulation on the rest of the country. That’s a laudable goal, but this measure almost certainly wouldn’t achieve it.

Relative to their budgets and economic footprint, the BEAD awards allocated to those two states are fairly minor.

California’s BEAD award is $1.9 billion and New York’s is only $664.6 million. By contrast, California’s annual budget is around $327 billion, and New York’s is roughly $254 billion. Both states can easily afford to simply pass on the BEAD funds altogether and ignore the moratorium.

Even if every other state took the BEAD funds and did away with enforcement—California and New York could eat the costs and move forward with enforcing European-style tech laws with ripple effects for the whole country.

Worse still, linking BEAD funding to the moratorium risks discouraging innovative states like Utah, Florida, and Tennessee from checking the woke policies of California and New York.

Rather than unleashing “permissionless innovation,” the moratorium could instead lead to rule-by-Sacramento and Albany—a scenario that should put fear in the heart of even the most ardent techno-libertarian.

BEAD has already been plagued by delays and red tape. This just adds one more layer of uncertainty.
It also leaves California and New York unimpeded while holding broadband funds for small conservative states and rural communities hostage.

Stepping back to consider the matter in broader terms, the proposed moratorium takes a profoundly wrongheaded attitude towards American federalism. Proponents of the moratorium see state regulations purely as impediments to heroic innovation.

But the advent of AI technologies presents a situation that as much as any calls to mind Justice Louis Brandeis’ dictum that the states are the laboratories of American democracy. New technologies, along with their benefits, have always created serious, destabilizing consequences.
Why not allow states to experiment with different means of addressing or mitigating the collateral costs that innovators would impose on society? Must we wait 10 years while these evils manifest before administering a remedy?

State regulation can be a necessary spur to innovators, forcing them to consider values outside of technical functionality and profitability. Some state regulations will be bad both in terms of their efficacy and in terms of the values they encode. Still, states should not be precluded from acting on behalf of their citizens, especially when Congress has no plan of its own.

Moreover, what Congress proposes to do by jeopardizing funding that states have received and relied on poses questions about the lawfulness of the moratorium. As the Supreme Court said just today, spending legislation like this takes the form of a “contract” with the states, not a “command.”

Federally funded programs like BEAD are agreements “between two sovereignties,” and when Congress offers states these or any other federal funds, what it is purchasing is a portion of the states’ sovereignty. Thus, the terms on which the money is offered must be clear, and the state’s consent truly voluntary.

If Congress is allowing funds to be de-obligated at the discretion of the Commerce Department and then subjecting their release to new, onerous terms, one might question whether the states’ consent to the new moratorium is truly voluntary.

At bottom, the moratorium would fail to achieve its primary goal of freeing AI from the clutches of large progressive states while also posing legal and constitutional challenges.
It’s time for Congress to see the light.

---

Part II

1) There is an apparent tug of war regarding the pending 'Big Beautiful Bill' that President Donald J. Trump (R) is attempting to herd his party's members in Congress into crossing the finish line. There are good reasons to do so, including, but not limited to, the benefits for tax reduction, clarity for markets and investors, support for the deportation and border control efforts, and more.

2) That said, federal lawmaking has long been compared to making sausage. It is an often-ugly process. Many would be turned off if they thought deeply about making sausage, and there could be a similar revulsion if someone spends a lot of time pondering the arm twisting, lobbying, and deal making that goes into getting a bill into law.

3) This writer has used AI for over two years on a near-daily basis. That said, AI has its pluses and minuses, as AI itself has admitted.

https://www.manufacturedhomepr...

4) It is anyone's guess how this will play out. But President Trump is pushing and his hoped for 'before' July 4 deadline is nearly upon us. Right or wrong, don't be surprised if AI interests and the president's desire to get the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act 119th Congress (2025-2026)" finished.

5) Legislation is ugly. But to be fair enforcement (or the lack thereof) of laws once enacted can be ugly too. The evidence for that is found in years of immigration law and border control often being improperly enforced. President Trump has demonstrated that Biden's claim that the border couldn't be fixed without new legislation was flawed at best, or intentionally misleading at worse.

6) In a similar fashion, Congress took a major step at 'solving' the affordable housing crisis almost 25 years ago, but improper enforcement of good existing federal laws leaves millions of Americans without an easy path to affordable and wealth-building home ownership. The lack of affordable housing is a major cause for homelessness, as HUD and other sources have admitted.

7) There is much to be fixed in our system. Sometimes the perfect is the enemy of the good, the great thinker G.K. Chesterton observed. Yours truly will continue to aim to keep you informed about, like it or not, reality. Other topics follow and that's a wrap for today's installment of the "Reality Check" series for this Patch.

Remember: facts matter. Evidence matters. Reality matters. The good Lord willing, more is coming in the days ahead to feast your eyes, mind, heart, and soul on. Thanks as always for checking in.

Mobile Home Manufacturers Association vs. Manufactured Housing Institute - Historic Peek at Parks-Production

'Someone can be wrong without lying. But if someone keeps saying or doing the same misleading things knowing they are wrong, they are lying'

'The Day That Dr. Franklin Saved the U.S. Constitutional Process and the Nation' - "The American Miracle"

'Opponents of Thesis America began as a Christian Nation Generally Ignore this Speech' Insights from Michael Medved's "The American Miracle"

HHS Plan for Prior Authorization Insurance Reform Way to Improve Patient Experience for Millions in U.S.

Dr. Mehmet Oz-Millions of Americans will Benefit from Trump Administration Plans for Prior Authorization Reform

‘$500 Million Dollars’ in ‘Prime Washington D.C. Real Estate is FOR SALE’ – Underused Federal Buildings

Trump Administration is seeking to reduce unnecessary costs identified by DOGE, plus an Update on the so-called POTUS Trump-Elon Musk Fued.

Three Politically Incorrect Cartoons by A.F. Branco via WND News Center to L. A. "Tony" Kovach for this Patch

Arabella Advisors and “Dark Money” Funding of Protests, Billionaires Ironically Funding "No Kings Day" Protests and Insights on DEMs and GOP

Romano Explains "Trading With The Enemy Act" "IEEPA" "Allows President To ‘Regulate… Importation’ Of Goods"

Robert Romano on Fed Law: 'National emergencies may be terminated by Presidential proclamation or by concurrent resolution of the Congress'

Hollis-Western Society will be Destroyed Without a Commitment to Truth

'Real education starts with a belief in objective truth and commitment to finding and promoting it. Western society will end without it.'

Emanuel-'Dem Party Weak and Woke' Amid Rumors Rahm wants White House

'Toxic' said former Obama-Biden era Chief of Staff and Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel slams Dems 'American Dream has Become Unaffordardable'

Poll: Strong Support Trump Priorities-Voters on Biden Health Coverup

New Poll Rising Approval for POTUS Trump’ Deporting Illegal Aliens and Strengthening Diplomatic ties in Middle Eastern nations to Serve U.S.---

Good, Bad, Ugly About Artificial Intelligence (AI): Problems-Solutions

Could AI become a "Skynet" or "Terminator" Style Threat to Humanity? What Can be Done to Control the Rapid Evolution of AI in our World?

Grok: Champion-Cavco Stock Slumps May Be Influenced by Trade Reporting

xAI-'Based on context and available data' 'MHProNews intensified reporting in recent months with AI fact Checks May Hit CVCO and SKY Stocks---

---

Grocery Prices See Biggest Drop in 5 Years as Trump Policies Take Hold

DCNF: "Grocery prices fell more in April than they have since 2020, driven by egg prices that saw their biggest drop in more than 40 years."

'Meticulous Review' of Bill Boor-MHI Remarks on U.S. Housing Shortage

'In a World Thirsty for Truth' Gemini Explained "How Hybrid Journalism Can Rebuild Trust and Uncover the Truth About Affordable Housing"---

President Trump Hints He'll Act Against More than Harvard University

"Billions of dollars has been paid to Harvard," POTUS Trump said. 'How ridiculous is that? Billions and they have a $52 billion endowment.'

Artificial Intelligence and Human Expert-AI Boosted Hybrid Journalism

The U.S. Affordable Housing Crisis is often Misunderstood. To Clarify Thorny Issues, Human Expertise & AI Boosted Fact Checks of Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI) and the Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR).

Tyler O'Neil - Doctors Throw Cold Water on Biden Claim on Cancer

---

WHAT THEY ARE SAYING: "Trillions in Great Deals"

White House Releases Formal Remarks by Corporate Leaders Praising "Trillions in Great Deals Secured for America Thanks to President Trump."

Hanne Nabintu Herland-Much Ado About History

What Marxist Philosophers did to the West, as Explained by Author and Historian Hanne Nabintu Herland - Why Understanding History Matters

Romano-Winning-Inflation Slowed 4.2025 to Lowest Level Since Feb 2021

Robert Romano Foreshadowed this Last Month - Inflation is Falling Despite Negative Tariff Talk by Media and 'Experts' like István Dobozi.

Can Reform of Corporate Governance Boost US Stocks Appeal and Economy?

---U.S. stocks equal nearly half of global stock markets - why are American Markets Appealing and What Could Make Them Even Better?

USDA Expands Access to Manufactured Home Loans-Zero Down Loan Option

Manufactured Housing Institute oddly fails to report the news of this potentially useful option for millions who seek affordable home option---

Trump Battle on Giant China Trade Deficit-is it Smart? Is it Popular?

'Vast Majority of Americans Say China is a Threat to U.S. - Manzanita Miller Presents Recent Research on Importance of a China Trade Fix

Accused of Hypocrisy-Fair?

Senator Bernie Sanders himself said that Democrats drifted from being the party of the working man to embracing financial elites-the latest.

Manzanita Miller's Research Reveals "Bad News for Democrats in-2026"

Manzanita Miller's said "Independent Voters Tend To Predict Sweeping Midterm Election Victories And That Is Bad News For Democrats In 2026."

Real Estate and Conventional Housing Dips, Manufactured Housing Rising

“The single-family home building market is facing competing concerns" said NAHB Chief Economist Robert Dietz.

DHS to Pay Illegal Aliens to Self-Deport to Save U.S. Time and Money?!

Jacob Adams-"The Department of Homeland Security is offering to pay for illegal

First U.S.A-Born Pope Draws Praise From Trump, Dems and Others; BUT...

Pope Leo XIV-First Look at the new Pope from U.S.A./North America. Praise, Concerns, Prayers Needed and Wanted for Cardinal Robert Francis.

How Advocates Like Fran Quigley-Robert Reich Shape Housing Narratives

Expert & Copilot Intro: how Corporations-Associations-Nonprofits-Advocates Omit Key Affordable Housing-Manufactured Home Facts+HUD's Turner

‘Endemic Mismanagement of HUD Manufactured Housing Program’ Nom Turner

'Restoring and Expanding Affordable Housing Role of Manufactured Homes'–MHARR Letter Cites 2000 Reform Act, "Enhanced Preemption" Much More

---

Real Estate and Conventional Housing Dips, Manufactured Housing Rising

“The single-family home building market is facing competing concerns" said NAHB Chief Economist Robert Dietz.

Danny Ghorbani-Seeking Alignment with Trump-Turner Vision and MHVille

"My heart is not to grow the amount of people on subsidies," said HUD Secretary E. Scott Turner in recent remarks on Affordable Housing.

David Dayen v Carrie Sheffield - Left/Right Views on NPR and PBS Cuts

Dayen says Trump looks 'Weak' for NPR/PBS Cut vs. Sheffield: 'Trump Rightly Defunded PBS-NPR History of Anti-Conservative Pro-Left Content'

DHS to Pay Illegal Aliens to Self-Deport to Save U.S. Time and Money?!

Jacob Adams-"The Department of Homeland Security is offering to pay for illegal aliens to return home to their native countries." Insight$

Robert Romano - After Trump’s First 100 Days, The Best Is Yet To Come

President Trump Promises as New Tax, Trade and Immigration Policies Take Hold the Joe Biden ‘Overhang’ Will Pass; Romano Presents Evidence.

Manufactured Home Groups Split in Transparency Amidst Housing Crisis

Blend of human expertise w/AI fact checks and commentary by Gemini, Copilot, and xAI's Grok help unpack causes-solutions to housing crisis.---

Electric Vehicles (EVs) Green? New and Prior Videos Spotlight Issues

Bethany Blankley: 'ICE Arrests Nearly 800 in Miami Florida Operation'

California’s Homeless Crisis Shows Need for Government Accountability

---

Top Florida Senate Democrat Quits: 'Dem Party in Florida Is Dead'

ActBlue - Two Sides of a Looming U.S. Democrats vs. Republicans Drama

Big Tech Accused of Crime of Illegally Hiring Immigrants vs. Americans

MHARR-Housing Supply Framework Act Could Benefit New Home Production

Pope Francis dies at 88 - What is next for the global Catholic Church?

---

Get Real Evidence for Jesus Christ, Easter & the Resurrection Miracle.

Dealmaker-In-Chief: Trump Given Room for Tariffs As Negotiation Tactic

American Dream of Homeownership is Slipping Away-Association Spotlight

Congressional Lawmakers "Monopoly Busters Caucus" to Fight High Costs

---

Young Leaders' Faith Behrens on Gov. Ron DeSantis and Florida's Future

Congress Must Now Cut Taxes and Regulations plus Trump Tariff Insights

ESG Ruling Puts New Pressure on Public Pension Funds and BlackRock

Trump Team Secures Southwest Land Border-Lowest Encounters Since 2000

---

Manufactured Housing Misses-Experts and Insiders Critique MHI Failures

Hybrid journalism blends human expertise and insights with AI backed fact checks: "Untapped Potential" "Action Over Apathy" Supplanting MHI

Real Reason Behind Left’s Freak-Out About the Department of Education?

Is There a Recession Ahead? John Carney's Fact-Packed Insight & Answer

---

Americans Mostly Support Trump On Deportation vs Activists Fighting it

Manzanita Miller unpacks new survey insight most 'Americans Side With Trump On Deportation—Not w/Activists Fighting For Illegals and Gangs.'

Lakeland Study Test Frank Rolfe Claim "Mobile Homes" Lower Prop Values

Hybrid Expert Human Study Combined with Multiple AI Powered Fact Checks plus 3rd Party Research Expose Disputed Claims in Critical Reporting

Manzanita Miller-Trump Tax Cut Helped Middle Class-Extension Welcomed

According to Manzanita Miller, the "Trump’s Tax Cuts Benefited The Middle-Class And That Is Why Extending Them Is Wildly Popular" LATK FEA--

New Manufactured Home Production Trend UP But Research Raises Concerns

Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR) Released Jan 2025 data that reflects continued improvements since 2023 but...

VP Vance-Illegal Immigrants Squeeze U.S. Citizens from Home Ownership

Bill Wilson - "A Mistake From The Past That Can Be Avoided"

GROK Affordable Housing Crisis Thesis-‘This Ain’t Theory—it’s a Heist’

Fact Checks by Grok-Copilot-Gemini Point to Problems at Manufactured Housing Institute that help Explain 21st Century Manufactured Home Sales

---

Is Decline in Christianity in U.S. Over? Pew Research Suggests It Is

Numbers of Those Praying and Attending Religious Services or Mass Have Stabilized According to Recent Findings Including a Big New Pew Study

Feb 2025 sees Lowest Number of Border Crossings in Modern USA History

HUD Sec Scott Turner Tension with HUD Research v Local Zoning Barriers

GROK reports on "Most Comprehensive" article on Sec Turner's recent remarks to WMAL, CPAC, and on challenges to solve affordable housing.

Dems Fretting Over Billionaires Are on Billionaire Dole for Years

Audrey Streb-for DCNF and via Daily Signal: Democratic Officials that Criticized Wealthy Despite Taking Funding from Billionaires (Ouch!)

Rob Romano-Who Controls Foreign Policy? President Or District Courts?

'Sexual Deviants' in Federal Service to be Fired-per DNI Tulsi Gabbard

More on those and other topics in this eclectic "Reality Check" series here on this Patch.

Big Majority Approve DOGE-Plus Political Cartoons to Muse and Amuse

THE Reality Check-All of Us Have Been Manipulated & Lied to-E. Nickson

Dan Bongino to FBI - 'We’re About to See it All. It’s All Coming Out.'

Larry Elder on 'Supercharging the U.S. Economy' Using a Proven Method

---

Democrats and GOP both 'Underwater' in New Poll-But Guess Which Leads?

By the Numbers - Evidence of Discrimination Against Believers in God

Employees! It is ‘Not Free Market Capitalism It’s Corporate Feudalism’

HUD Sec Turner-'Corporate Takeover of Housing—A Manufactured Crisis'

'Trump Is Leading a Historic Counterrevolution Against the Deep State'

Federal Racket-Follow the Money-Tammany Hall 2.0 and Big U.S. Media

U.S. Manufactured Home Industry Production 2024 Total Up per MHARR

(Note MHARR is short for the Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform.)

Scott Turner Confirmed Secretary of Housing and Urban Development-Official HUD+Manufactured Housing Association for Regulatory Reform (MHARR) News Releases; Manufactured Home Generational Wealth

> ‘Endemic Mismanagement of HUD Manufactured Housing Program’ Nom Turner

'Restoring and Expanding Affordable Housing Role of Manufactured Homes'–MHARR Letter Cites 2000 Reform Act, "Enhanced Preemption" Much More...https://patch.com/florida/lake...

> Big Govt, Big Pharma, Big Food made Americans Overweight and Unhealthy

> Virginia Bishop for ‘Well-Regulated Borders’ Amid VP J.D. Vance Rumble

> Romano-Trump Bans DEI In Federal Govt—States And Corporations Are Next

> How Republicans Should Follow Through on Tough Talk on Immigration

> NPR=87 Registered Democrats in Editorial Positions and No Republicans

> President Donald J. Trump’s Official 'America First Priorities'

---

> Rubio Senate Replacement Ashley Moody (FL-R) Gets Key Assignments

> Trump Plan: Make America Safe, Affordable, Restore U.S. Values for All

---

> Official Manufactured Housing Production from 1995-2023-Why it Matters

> Anna Paulina Luna (FL-R) and Barry Loudermilk (GA-R) MERIT Act Insight

> Executive Orders on Investigating Biden Censorship & Weaponization

> Floridian Dr István Dobozi Strikes at Trump Again in Magyar Article (Another critical analysis - fact check).

---

> Why do Liars Lie? Why do those Engaged in Paltering and Spin Palter?

> Controversy-Manufactured Housing Institute-Lesli Gooch-Mark Bowersox

> ‘Mobile Home Values Rising Faster Than Single-Family’ House-Wow Fact$

> Realtor-What Is a Manufactured Home? The Next Step Beyond Mobile Homes

> Orlando RE Agent Smith-Younger Adults Will Need $8500 Monthly for Rent

---

> Rob Romano-Time To Declassify Everything, Or Another RussiaGate Ahead

> Contemporary Tips from Legend Paul Harvey-Surprising Rest of the Story

> Alert: Is Affordable Housing Linked Scandal at Champion Homes Brewing?

> Report: Biden-Harris Federal Agencies Spent Millions Torturing Cats

> Lesli Gooch Ph.D.-Award, Coverup, Headfake, Scandal? Rest of the Story (Manufactured Housing Institute linked)

---

> ALG Unpacks Trump Pitch to Cut Drug Costs by Cutting PBM Middleman

> Is there Evidence that God Exists? Evolution vs. Intelligent Design

> Democratic Voters-Closer Look at Biden’s Acts Before Biden-Harris Exit

> Christian Leaders-Signs of 4th 'Great Awakening' Millions go to Jesus

> Attorney John Morgan - Democrat Megadonor on Kamala Harris Campaign

---

> USA Today - David Plouffe and Dem Advisers on Kamala Harris Revelation

> Majority OK Trump Transition-Mass Deportations-Tariffs- Is it Hopeful?

> Niskanen Center Praises Manufactured Home ‘Cost Savings’ and ‘Quality’

> Alice Carter-The Northern Forum-Deporting Immigrants & Housing Crisis

> Cartoons-Kamala Day 1, DOGE the Swamp, Brainwashing, & Out In the Cold

---

> The Creepy Line-Peter Schweizer-Dr. Jordan Peterson-Dr. Robert Epstein

> Secret State Miniseries - Fictional TV Series Shed Light on Reality

> Trump Transition Team Asked to Prioritize Affordable Housing Issues

> Top 10 States for Homelessness & Top Cities for Crime=Shocking Lessons

> WashPost-American Dream Fades But Assoc CEO Mark Weiss Shows Solution

---

> Blankley-Goodbye American Dream? Only 10% Polled Can Buy a House; But

> Frank Rolfe-Special Interests ‘Don’t Want to Solve Affordable Housing'

> TARK-‘I’m a Teen and Know the Solution to Affordable Housing Crisis’

---> Renting? Rent too High? Odds Are DOJ Suit vs RealPage Matters to You

> New-Certified “Half Price Homes” - Affordable Housing Solution Redux

---

> Solution: “Would-Be Homebuyers Need 80% More Income Than 4 Years Ago”

L. A. “Tony” Kovach is a publisher who has earned multiple awards in history. He and his family live in a manufactured home on private property in Winter Haven, FL. He is the co-founder of Manufactured Home Living News.com (MHLivingNews.com) and Manufactured Home Pro News.com (MHProNews.com), trade publications serving segments of the manufactured home industry. Having worked in several segments of the manufactured home industry for over 3 decades, Kovach is a widely acknowledged and often praised expert on manufactured housing. ###

Share